At the ready
Amazon Echo Show 10 (3rd Gen)
$250 at Amazon $250 at Best Buy $250 at B&H
Pros
- Excellent sound quality
- The rotating display can be beneficial
- Great camera
- Video call powerhouse
Cons
- Takes up a lot of counter space
- Some widgets can be hard to see on this screen size
- A camera that can follow you may be unnerving to some
The new Echo Show 10 is the ultimate smart speaker for multitaskers. Thanks to an improved camera and a display that can rotate to track you, whether it's during a video call or following a recipe. With three speakers, it also has excellent sound quality. At 10 inches, the display is large enough when close, but some content may be hard to read at a distance.
Go big
Amazon Echo Show 15
Pros
- The large display is perfect for multiple widgets
- Can be used in landscape or portrait mode
- Wall-mountable
- Looks excellent in photo frame mode
Cons
- Display stands sold separately
- Lower quality camera
- The speakers aren't great
At 15 inches, the Echo Show 15 is wall-mountable and the most prominent smart display from Amazon; it brings a lot of new functionality. With plenty of space to expand, your widgets and daily calendar can be easily seen. There is a built-in camera, but its quality isn't fantastic, and neither are the speakers. However, as a smart photo frame — it's hard to beat.
Amazon kicked off the smart speaker competition with the original Echo in 2014, and while there are many other companies in the space these days, the Echo line is still some of the best smart speakers on the market. This is because Amazon continues to improve and expand the lineup. The Echo Show product line brings a lot of functionality, and the battle of the big screen variety, the Echo Show 10 vs. Echo Show 15, is where it all really shines. But which is the best — let's find out.
Echo Show 15 vs. Echo Show 10: Room to expand
Whether big or small, the availability of a display on a smart speaker is super helpful. Having visual cues and control via touch expands the functionality of an already helpful digital assistant even more. A larger display size means there's room for more information, and what is on the screen can be bigger and less cramped.
When Amazon released the third generation of the Echo Show 10 in early 2021, it made some pretty significant changes to the form factor. The screen size remained the same as previous versions, but nearly everything else is different. For example, the display can now spin around the three speakers set up so that it can always face you. This means that when on a video call using the much improved 13MP camera, both people will see each other.
Its rotating screen also means that using the Echo Show 10 for recipes is very helpful. If you've ever tried to use your smart display while cooking, you know that it can be frustrating at times. When you're moving around your kitchen and have to go back to the static display, it can take you out of your flow. But depending on how large the room you have the Echo Show 10 in, that info may be tough to read on the 10-inch display.
Speaking of flow, the dual tweeters and the subwoofer in the new Echo Show 10 sound great. The output is full and balanced for all audio. So whether you listen to a playlist from Amazon Music to get through a house cleaning session or a video call, it will all sound wonderful. While the Echo Show 15 does have a dual speaker setup, it's going to be missing a lot of the low-end sounds that the subwoofer in the Echo Show 10 offers.
| Echo Show 10 (3rd Gen) | Echo Show 15 --- | --- | --- Display | 10.1 inches, 1280x800, touchscreen | 15.6 inches, 1920x1080, touchscreen Dimensions | 9.9 x 9 x 6.7 inches (251 x 230 x 172mm) |
15.8 x 9.9 x 1.4 inches (402 x 252 x 35mm) Weight | 90.3 oz (2560 g) | 78.1 oz (2215 g) Processor | MediaTek 8183, plus second processor with Amazon AZ1 Neural Edge chip | Amlogic Pop1 octa-core SoC with Amazon AZ2 neural network engine Camera | 13MP | 5 MP Connectivity | 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac, Bluetooth A2DP | 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac, Bluetooth A2DP Speakers | 2 x 1" tweeters and 1 x 3.0" woofer | Dual 1.6" full-range drivers Privacy features | wake word (Alexa), streaming indicator lights, microphone/camera off button, camera shutter, delete voice recordings, disable motion | wake word (Alexa), streaming indicator lights, microphone/camera off button, camera shutter, delete voice recordings Motion | Brushless motor with +/- 175-degree rotation | ❌ Smart home hub | Zigbee and Amazon Sidewalk | Amazon Sidewalk Colors | Charcoal and Glacier White | White border w/black frame
Where the Echo Show 15 lacks in sound quality, it more than makes up for in-screen real estate. The expansive 15-inch full-HD display makes full use of the new widgets announced summer of 2021. The calendar integration and personalized notes are extremely useful on this Echo Show 15. Thanks to the inclusion of Alexa and a 5MP camera, the content displayed on-screen can be individually personalized to anyone in the home. Features I'd love to have in my homemade digital wall calendar.
Though the Echo Show 10 offers the same widgets and personalization options as its larger sibling, at times, the smaller screen can be a bit cramped in comparison. Another feature unique to the Echo Show 15 is that you can mount it to a wall. Depending on how you want to use the display, it can be hung either in portrait or landscape orientation.
There is also a stand for the Echo Show 15 if wall mounting isn't an option or you prefer showing it off on a table. Whereas the Echo Show 10 is only going to sit on a tabletop or a shelf. Regardless of where you set the smart display, it's going to take up a fair amount of space. Perhaps one area where the larger Echo Show 15 stands out the most is a digital photo frame.
Both of these Echo Show devices can make displays for your photo albums, but the Echo Show 15's design has a slight edge. That's because it looks like a photo frame even when it's not on. So when your photos are hanging on the wall, shown on the 1080p HD display, it tends to give a bit more gravitas to your pictures.
Amazon Echo Show 15 vs. Echo Show 10 (3rd Gen): Which should you buy?
Both of these smart displays can execute the full breadth of what Amazon's Alexa ecosystem has to offer, from watching movies to smart home controls. The decision really comes down to what your personal use cases will be. If you value great sound quality for music and video calls, then the Echo Show 10 likely will suit you best. On the subject of video calls, the higher-quality 13MP camera in the Echo Show 10 and the rotating display will lead to an overall better experience.
However, if you are looking for a display that can act as a hub for your home — the Echo Show 15 may be the better choice. That's because the larger screen can make calendars, reminders, shopping lists, and more easier to read and allows for more info to be displayed. It also makes for a better photo frame and screen for movies, thanks to the higher resolution. However, the lower camera quality and larger size won't be ideal for everyone.
In the end, these are both excellent options if you are looking for an Amazon smart display. The Echo product line is growing and gaining useful new features regularly. There are a lot of excellent Alexa devices to choose from, but the Echo Show 10 and Show 15 are the biggest — and arguably the most useful. Which is best for you comes down to what features you value most.
Keep it on a swivel
Amazon Echo Show 10 (3rd Gen)
Booming sound
$250 at Amazon $250 at Best Buy $250 at B&H
The Echo Show 10 may well be the most capable smart speaker yet, thanks to the excellent speakers, high-quality 13MP camera, and a 10-inch display that can rotate so that it's always in perfect view.
Smart art
Amazon Echo Show 15
Hub of operations
From displaying photos to managing your schedules, the Echo Show 15 is perfect for almost any home. The full-HD screen is put to great use when showing calendars, reminders, and of course, pictures.
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar